Build vs. Buy Master Data Management Software

Master Data Management Blog by Stibo Systems logo
| 4 minute read
January 28 2022

Master data management software: build or buy? The complete guide

When it comes to implementing a master data management software solution, organizations have the option of either building one in-house or buying a pre-built software solution from a vendor. Both options have their own set of advantages and disadvantages, and the choice of which to go for will depend on your organization's unique needs and resources.

In this blog post, we will outline the major advantages and disadvantages of building vs. buying a master data management software solution. Also, we take you through the six most important questions to consider, when making this decision. Finally, we will provide you with evaluation criteria for selecting a vendor or building in-house such that this blog post cover all the key considerations that will help you make the best decision for your organization.

solution_STEP-MDM-platform_shutterstock_527546032

What are the advantages and disadvantages of building vs. buying a master data management software solution?

The advantages of buying a master data management software include:

  1. Proven functionality and capabilities: Buying a master data management software means that the product has already been tested and proven to work effectively, reducing the risk of implementation failure.

  2. Time and cost savings: Buying a pre-built software can save a significant amount of time and money compared to building one from scratch.

  3. Access to expert support and maintenance: When purchasing a master data management software, organizations will have access to expert support and maintenance to ensure the product is running smoothly and any issues are resolved quickly.

  4. Regular updates and upgrades: Buying a master data management software means that the product will be updated and upgraded on a regular basis to ensure it remains current and effective.

  5. Scalability: Buying a master data management software can provide the flexibility to scale up or down as business needs change, providing a scalable solution to meet the organization's future needs.

The disadvantages of buying a master data management software include:

  1. High costs: Buying a master data management software solution can be expensive.
  2. Limited flexibility: Purchasing a commercial master data management software solution may not be able to meet all of the organization's unique requirements.
  3. Dependence on the vendor: By purchasing a master data management software, organizations may be dependent on the vendor for support and future upgrades.
  4. Potential difficulties with customization: Buying a commercial software solution may not be as easy to customize as a home-grown solution.


The advantages of building a master data management software include:

  1. Customization: Building a master data management software allows organizations to tailor the solution to their specific needs and requirements.

  2. Control: Building a master data management software gives organizations more control over the development and maintenance of the software.

  3. Integration: Building a master data management software allows organizations to easily integrate the software with their existing systems and infrastructure. However, most vendors offer integrations to a broad variety of systems today.

  4. Cost savings: Building a master data management software can potentially be more cost-effective in the long run as organizations can avoid ongoing licensing fees associated with buying a solution.

The disadvantages of building a master data management software include:

  1. High development costs: Building a master data management software solution is highly expensive as the organization needs to invest in the necessary resources such as developers, hardware, and software.
  2. Increased time to market: Building a master data management software from scratch takes longer than buying an existing one.
  3. Limited functionality and scalability: A home-grown solution may not have the same level of functionality and scalability as a commercial master data management software solution.
  4. Difficulty in integrating with other systems: Building a master data management software solution may not be as easy to integrate with other systems as a commercial solution.

 

 

6 questions to consider when deciding on whether to build or buy a master data management software solution: 

1. What are the requirements of this software?

These are likely to change over time, but what are, for example, you business and architectural requirements?

2. Are your business requirements urgent?

Do you have enough time to dedicate your in-house resources to building a solution?

3. Have you analyzed your existing technology landscape?

Are there perhaps other teams in your company that have similar needs?

Do you have existing technology that could address the requirements?

4. How will the solution be supported? By whom?

Who are your business stakeholders, and how should your software solution be supported from a technical standpoint?

5. Do you have the available in-house resources to create the software solution?

Do you have enough in-house expertise to build a system, synthesize the requirements, architect the solution, debug the software, and also plan for future needs and scalability?

6. Will your data software solution be tactical or strategic? 

Your IT staff may be able to meet a current need, but can that solution scale to also meet future needs

These six essential questions on whether to buy or build a master data management software, will provide you with an overview of the advantages and disadvantages attached to each solution. Thus, when having answered all these questions, you will have found the optimal solution for your organization in terms of whether to build or buy your master data management software solution. 

 

Evaluation criteria for selecting a vendor or building a master data management software solution in-house

Key evaluation criteria for selecting a vendor or building a master data management software solution inhouse could for example include the following: 

  1. Data governance and management capabilities: It is important to consider how well the vendor or in-house solution can handle data governance and management tasks such as data quality, data lineage, and data security.

  2. Scalability and performance: The software solution should be able to handle large volumes of data and provide fast performance.

  3. Integration with existing systems: The vendor or in-house master data management software solution should be able to integrate with existing systems and data sources, such as CRM and ERP systems.

  4. Data modeling and transformation capabilities: The software solution should be able to handle data modeling and transformation tasks, such as data mapping, data cleansing, and data integration.

  5. User interface and ease of use: The master data management software should have a user-friendly interface that is easy to navigate and use.

  6. Technical support and maintenance: The vendor or in-house software solution should provide adequate technical support and maintenance services to ensure that the system is running smoothly and that any issues are quickly resolved.

  7. Cost: The vendor or in-house master data management software solution should be cost-effective and provide value for money.

  8. Flexibility: The software solution should be flexible enough to meet the specific needs of the organization.

  9. Technical expertise: The vendor or in-house team should have the necessary technical expertise to support the implementation and maintenance of the system.

  10. Security: The master data management software should provide robust security features to protect data from unauthorized access, breaches, and other threats.


Topics: 
Master Data Management Blog by Stibo Systems logo

Katja is a seasoned digital strategist with a 10-year track record of helping businesses across different industries drive digital growth and improve their digital experience.

Discover Blogs by Topic

  • MDM strategy
  • Data governance
  • Customer and party data
  • See more
  • Retail and distribution
  • Manufacturing
  • Data quality
  • Supplier data
  • Product data and PIM
  • AI and machine learning
  • CPG
  • Financial services
  • GDPR
  • Sustainability
  • Location data
  • PDX Syndication

Navigating Change: Engaging Business Users in Successful Change Management

9/20/24

What is Digital Asset Management?

9/11/24

How to Improve Your Data Management

9/3/24

The Future of Master Data Management: Trends in 2023-2025

9/1/24

Digital Transformation in the CPG Industry

8/30/24

5 CPG Industry Trends and Opportunities for 2024-2025

8/29/24

What is the difference between CPG and FMCG?

8/27/24

Responsible AI relies on data governance

8/27/24

6 Features of an Effective Master Data Management Solution

8/15/24

Great Data Minds: The Unsung Heros Behind Effective Data Management

8/13/24

A Data Monetization Strategy - Get More Value from Your Master Data

8/6/24

Introducing the Master Data Management Maturity Model

8/4/24

What is Augmented Data Management? (ADM)

7/31/24

Data Migration to SAP S/4HANA ERP - The Fast and Safe Approach with MDM

7/30/24

Data Governance and Data Protection: A Match Made in Heaven?

7/17/24

The Difference Between Master Data and Metadata

5/26/24

Master Data Management Roles and Responsibilities

5/20/24

8 Best Practices for Customer Master Data Management

5/16/24

What Is Master Data Governance – And Why Do You Need It?

5/12/24

Guide: Deliver flawless rich content experiences with master data governance

4/11/24

Risks of Using LLMs in Your Business – What Does OWASP Have to Say?

4/10/24

Guide: How to comply with industry standards using master data governance

4/9/24

Digital Product Passports - A Data Management Challenge

4/8/24

Guide: Get enterprise data enrichment right with master data governance

4/2/24

Guide: Getting enterprise data modelling right with master data governance

4/2/24

Guide: Improving your data quality with master data governance

4/2/24

Data Governance Trends 2024

1/30/24

NRF 2024 Recap: In the AI era, better data can make all the difference

1/19/24

Building Supply Chain Resilience: Strategies & Examples

12/19/23

How Master Data Management Can Enhance Your ERP Solution

12/14/23

Shedding Light on Climate Accountability and Traceability in Retail

11/29/23

What is Smart Manufacturing and Why Does it Matter?

10/11/23

Future Proof Your Retail Business with Composable Commerce

10/9/23

5 Common Reasons Why Manufacturers Fail at Digital Transformation

10/5/23

How to Digitally Transform a Restaurant Chain

9/29/23

Three Benefits of Moving to Headless Commerce and the Role of a Modern PIM

9/14/23

12 Steps to a Successful Omnichannel and Unified Commerce

7/6/23

CGF Global Summit 2023: Unlock Sustainable Growth With Collaboration and Innovation

7/5/23

Navigating the Current Challenges of Supply Chain Management

6/28/23

Product Data Management during Mergers and Acquisitions

4/6/23

A Complete Master Data Management Glossary

3/14/23

4 Ways to Reduce Ecommerce Returns

3/8/23

Asset Data Governance is Central for Asset Management

3/1/23

4 Common Master Data Management Implementation Styles

2/21/23

How to Leverage Internet of Things with Master Data Management

2/14/23

Manufacturing Trends and Insights in 2023-2025

2/14/23

Sustainability in Retail Needs Governed Data

2/13/23

NRF 2023: Retail Turns to AI and Automation to Increase Efficiencies

1/20/23

5 Key Manufacturing Challenges in 2023

1/16/23

What is a Golden Customer Record in Master Data Management?

1/9/23

Innovation in Retail

1/4/23

Life Cycle Assessment Scoring for Food Products

11/21/22

Retail of the Future

11/14/22

Omnichannel Strategies for Retail

11/7/22

Hyper-Personalized Customer Experiences Need Multidomain MDM

11/5/22

What is Omnichannel Retailing and What is the Role of Data Management?

10/25/22

Most Common ISO Standards in the Manufacturing Industry

10/18/22

How to Get Started with Master Data Management: 5 Steps to Consider

10/17/22

What is Supply Chain Analytics and Why It's Important

10/12/22

What is Data Quality and Why It's Important

10/12/22

An Introductory Guide: What is Data Intelligence?

10/1/22

Revolutionizing Manufacturing: 5 Must-Have SaaS Systems for Success

9/15/22

An Introductory Guide to Supplier Compliance

9/7/22

What is Application Data Management and How Does It Differ From MDM?

8/29/22

Digital Transformation in the Manufacturing Industry

8/25/22

Master Data Management Framework: Get Set for Success

8/17/22

Discover the Value of Your Data: Master Data Management KPIs & Metrics

8/15/22

Supplier Self-Service: Everything You Need to Know

6/15/22

Omnichannel vs. Multichannel: What’s the Difference?

6/14/22

Create a Culture of Data Transparency - Begin with a Solid Foundation

6/10/22

The 5 Biggest Retail Trends for 2023-2025

5/31/22

What is a Location Intelligence?

5/31/22

Omnichannel Customer Experience: The Ultimate Guide

5/30/22

Location Analytics – All You Need to Know

5/26/22

Omnichannel Commerce: Creating a Seamless Shopping Experience

5/24/22

Top 4 Data Management Trends in the Insurance Industry

5/11/22

What is Supply Chain Visibility and Why It's Important

5/1/22

The Ultimate Guide to Data Transparency

4/21/22

How Manufacturers Can Shift to Product-as-a-Service Offerings

4/20/22

How to Check Your Enterprise Data Foundation

4/16/22

An Introductory Guide to Manufacturing Compliance

4/14/22

Multidomain MDM vs. Multiple Domain MDM

3/31/22

Making Master Data Accessible: What is Data as a Service (DaaS)?

3/29/22

How to Build a Successful Data Governance Strategy

3/23/22

What is Unified Commerce? Key Advantages & Best Practices

3/22/22

How to Choose the Right Data Quality Tool?

3/22/22

What is a data domain? Meaning & examples

3/21/22

6 Best Practices for Data Governance

3/17/22

5 Advantages of a Master Data Management System

3/16/22

A Unified Customer View: What Is It and Why You Need It

3/9/22

Supply Chain Challenges in the CPG Industry

2/24/22

The Best Data Governance Tools You Need to Know About

2/17/22

Top 5 Most Common Data Quality Issues

2/14/22

What Is Synthetic Data and Why It Needs Master Data Management

2/10/22

What is Cloud Master Data Management?

2/8/22

How to Implement Data Governance

2/7/22

Build vs. Buy Master Data Management Software

1/28/22

Why is Data Governance Important?

1/27/22

Five Reasons Your Data Governance Initiative Could Fail

1/24/22

How to Turn Your Data Silos Into Zones of Insight

1/21/22

How to Improve Supplier Experience Management

1/16/22

​​How to Improve Supplier Onboarding

1/16/22

How to Enable a Single Source of Truth with Master Data Management

1/13/22

What is a Data Quality Framework?

1/11/22

How to Measure the ROI of Master Data Management

1/11/22

What is Manufacturing-as-a-Service (MaaS)?

1/7/22

The Ultimate Guide to Building a Data Governance Framework

1/4/22

Master Data Management Tools - and Why You Need Them

12/20/21

The Dynamic Duo of Data Security and Data Governance

12/20/21

How to Choose the Right Supplier Management Solution

12/20/21

How Data Transparency Enables Sustainable Retailing

12/6/21

What is Supplier Performance Management?

12/1/21

What is Party Data? All You Need to Know About Party Data Management

11/28/21

What is Data Compliance? An Introductory Guide

11/18/21

How to Create a Marketing Center of Excellence

11/14/21

The Complete Guide: How to Get a 360° Customer View

11/7/21

How Location Data Adds Value to Master Data Projects

10/29/21

How Marketers Should Prepare for the 2023 Holiday Shopping Season

10/26/21

What is Supplier Lifecycle Management?

10/19/21

What is a Data Mesh? A Simple Introduction

10/15/21

How to Build a Master Data Management Strategy

9/26/21

10 Signs You Need a Master Data Management Platform

9/2/21

What Vendor Data Is and Why It Matters to Manufacturers

8/31/21

3 Reasons High-Quality Supplier Data Can Benefit Any Organization

8/25/21

4 Trends in the Automotive Industry

8/11/21

What is Reference Data and Reference Data Management?

8/9/21

What Obstacles Are Impacting the Global Retail Recovery?

8/2/21

GDPR as a Catalyst for Effective Data Governance

7/25/21

All You Need to Know About Supplier Information Management

7/21/21

5 Tips for Driving a Centralized Data Management Strategy

7/3/21

Welcome to the Decade of Transparency

5/26/21

How to Become a Customer-Obsessed Brand

5/12/21

How to Create a Master Data Management Roadmap in Five Steps

4/27/21

What is a Data Catalog? Definition and Benefits

4/13/21

How to Improve the Retail Customer Experience with Data Management

4/8/21

How to Choose the Right Master Data Management Solution

3/29/21

Business Intelligence and Analytics: What's the Difference?

3/25/21

Spending too much on Big Data? Try Small Data and MDM

3/24/21

What is a Data Lake? Everything You Need to Know

3/21/21

How to Extract More Value from Your Data

3/17/21

Are you making decisions based on bad HCO/HCP information?

2/24/21

Why Master Data Cleansing is Important to CPG Brands

1/20/21

CRM 2.0 – It All Starts With Master Data Management

12/19/20

5 Trends in Telecom that Rely on Transparency of Master Data

12/15/20

10 Data Management Trends in Financial Services

11/19/20

Seasonal Marketing Campaigns: What Is It and Why Is It Important?

11/8/20

What Is a Data Fabric and Why Do You Need It?

10/29/20

Transparent Product Information in Pharmaceutical Manufacturing

10/14/20

How to Improve Back-End Systems Using Master Data Management

9/19/20

8 Benefits of Transparent Product Information for Medical Devices

9/1/20

How Retailers Can Increase Online Sales in 2023

8/23/20

Master Data Management (MDM) & Big Data

8/14/20

Key Benefits of Knowing Your Customers

8/9/20

Women in Master Data: Kelly Amavisca, Ferguson

8/5/20

Customer Data in Corporate Banking Reveal New Opportunities

7/21/20

How to Analyze Customer Data With Customer Master Data Management

7/21/20

How to Improve Your 2023 Black Friday Sales in 5 Steps

7/18/20

4 Ways Product Information Management (PIM) Improves the Customer Experience

7/18/20

How to Estimate the ROI of Your Customer Data

7/1/20

Women in Master Data: Rebecca Chamberlain, M&S

6/24/20

How to Personalise Insurance Solutions with MDM

6/17/20

How to Democratize Your Data

6/3/20

How to Get Buy-In for a Master Data Management Solution

5/25/20

How CPG Brands Manage the Impact of Covid-19 in a Post-Pandemic World

5/18/20

5 Steps to Improve Your Data Syndication

5/7/20

Marketing Data Quality: Why Is It Important and How to Get Started

3/26/20

Panic Buying: Navigating Long-term Implications and Uncertainty

3/24/20

Women in Master Data: Ditte Brix, IMPACT

2/20/20

Get More Value From Your CRM With Customer Master Data Management

2/17/20

Women in Master Data: Nagashree Devadas, Stibo Systems

2/4/20

How to Create Direct-to-Consumer (D2C) Success for CPG Brands

1/3/20

Women in Master Data: Anna Schéle, Ahlsell

10/25/19

Women in Master Data: Morgan Lawrence, Infoverity

9/26/19

Women in Master Data: Sara Friberg, Acando (Part of CGI)

9/13/19

Improving Product Setup Processes Enhances Superior Experiences

8/21/19

How to Improve Your Product's Time to Market With PDX Syndication

7/18/19

8 Tips For Pricing Automation In The Aftermarket

6/1/19

How to Drive Innovation With Master Data Management

3/15/19

Discover PDX Syndication to Launch New Products with Speed

2/27/19

How to Benefit from Product Data Management

2/20/19

What is a Product Backlog and How to Avoid It

2/13/19

How to Get Rid of Customer Duplicates

2/7/19

4 Types of IT Systems That Should Be Sunsetted

1/3/19

How to Use Customer Data Modeling

11/15/18

How to Reduce Time-to-Market with Master Data Management

10/28/18

How to Start Taking Advantage of Your Data

9/12/18

6 Signs You Have a Potential GDPR Problem

8/16/18

GDPR: The DOs and DON’Ts of Personal Data

6/13/18

How Master Data Management Supports Data Security

6/7/18

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ) About the GDPR

5/30/18

Understanding the Role of a Chief Data Officer

4/26/18

3 Steps: How to Plan, Execute and Evaluate Any IoT Initiative

2/20/18

How to Benefit From Customer-Centric Data Management

9/7/17

3 Ways to Faster Innovation with Multidomain Master Data Management

6/7/17

Product Information Management Trends to Consider

5/25/17

4 Major GDPR Challenges and How to Solve Them

5/12/17

How to Prepare for GDPR in Five Steps

2/21/17

How Data Can Help Fight Counterfeit Pharmaceuticals

1/24/17

Create the Best Customer Experience with a Customer Data Platform

1/11/17