Stibo Systems - The Master Data Management Company

Life Cycle Assessment Scoring for Food Products

Master Data Management Blog by Stibo Systems logo
| 8 minute read
November 21 2022

The French-based Eco-Score is indicative of the challenges in grocery retail who needs to calculate and communicate product lifecycles and sustainability data. It requires unified data management and a diverse skill set.

Picture of a woman getting groceries in a supermarket.


Picture of Paarijat Bose, Senior Consultant, Stibo SystemsInterview with Paarijat Bose, Senior Consultant, Stibo Systems, about sustainability scoring and life cycle assessment for food products.

Prior to joining Stibo Systems, Paarijat worked as a business consultant at a major Belgian retailer. In this role she facilitated the accuracy of sustainability data, mapping requirements for products. She ensured the correctness of sustainability information and created information models and data lineage. With this background, Paarijat has in-depth knowledge about a topic that is high on many retailers’ agenda right now: life cycle assessment scoring and sustainability data management. We asked her to share some of that knowledge, specifically how to obtain and calculate sustainability data to make it fit for scoring.

Grocery retailers are facing a huge challenge regarding sustainability because they need to communicate product life cycle assessments to consumers. But where should they start? Expectations are high and so is the number of new sustainability standards that seem to crop up daily.

There are several standards based on numerical parameters, such as Product Environmental Footprint, Life Cycle Assessment (LCA) score and Green Premium which can easily be overwhelming for retailers and their customers. These are calculation methods to be used when it comes to KPIs and industrial performance metrics but what matters the most to retailers is the simplified indicator like Digital Product Passport (for textiles, construction, industrial, electric vehicle and batteries) or Eco-Score (for food) that simplifies the concept and makes it easy to choose products that are good for both consumers and the environment.

This kind of easy-to-understand number or indicator can also help retailers promote environmentally friendly products, increase sales to the conscious customer and monitor easily comparative metrics for sustainability reporting as well. Take the Eco-Score as an example.



Please, elaborate on the Eco-Score

The Eco-Score is an indicator of the ecological footprint of a food product. It is modeled after the Nutri-Score, which calculates the nutritional value of a product. The Eco-Score has a coloured logo in the shape of a leaf with a letter from A (low environmental impact) to E (very high environmental impact). This score can help support more sustainable food choices, promote virtuous agricultural practices, minimize resource utilization, reduce global warming and preserve life for future generations.

The methodology to calculate the Eco-Score was developed by a group of eight independent players in France: ECO2 Initiative, Etiquettable, FoodChéri, Marmiton, Open Food Facts, ScanUp, Seazon and Yuka. The score was introduced in January 2021 with the aim of giving customers instant information on the environmental impact of a product and thus helping them to consume more sustainably. Colruyt Group launched the Eco-score in Belgium in March 2021, Carrefour announced the score on the packaging of many products in France. In the same year, Lidl Belgium also started displaying Eco-Score on their products. In the meantime, the Eco-score can be found through more and more channels: not only on the packaging or price labels of many products but through barcode scanners and search functions also in apps and on various websites. In addition to the scores of retailers' private label products, the scores of national brand products are increasingly available.


Is there any legal basis for the Eco-Score?

As of today, Eco-Score is a voluntary product label by a joint voluntary effort of players in the domains of computing, distribution and catering. They have a common ambition: to create a simple tool that can be used by all to reduce the impact of food production on the planet. This consortium decided to create an independent, transparent and collaborative methodology based on available public data.


In 2021, the European Commission registered a European Citizens’ Initiative calling for a “European Eco-Score” to inform consumers about the ecological impact on product labeling.

The European Commission is expected to put forward a proposal for an EU-wide food labeling scheme at the end of 2022. This framework will consider nutritional aspects (like in Nutri-Score) useful to support public health objectives, as well as sustainable and social elements of food products (targeted in Eco-Score). We need to wait to know if the Eco-Score made it in the list of mandates or if a new framework is proposed.

Since the Eco-Score is a voluntary measure, there is no penalty involved. However, when a standard obligation comes from the EU, the situation might change as it has for nutritional information that is mandated in certain EU countries and in the UK.


How do you calculate the Eco-Score?

The Eco-Score is a sum-up of the Life Cycle Assessment (LCA) score of the product itself, along with some bonus points and penalty points (also known as malus points) based on the product packaging, production processes, supply chain parameters like travel, the policies of the countries involved, and whether the product affects any endangered species.

Image text that shows how to calculate the Eco-Score. The image is explained in the blog text.

Image source: 

The Life Cycle Assessment part of the Eco-Score is calculated from public data produced by ADEME (the French Agency for Ecological Transition) and INRAE, a public research institute working for the coherent and sustainable development of agriculture, food and the environment, within the framework of the Agribalyse project. It evaluates the average environmental impact of 2,500 product categories, such as biscuit for breakfast, biscuit for breakfast with reducing sugars, biscuit for breakfast with chocolate, etc., which are very detailed in each category.


Can you shed some light on the teams and profiles involved in the calculation of the Eco-Score for a retailer

Sustainability data management is a vast topic that needs an array of niche skills even though the actual team size can be moderate. If I just focus on the Eco-Score for food industries, a retailer will need sustainability advisors and dietitians, along with data governance specialists, data scientists, product information experts and supplier relationship managers, as well as sourcing/procurement advisors.

Obviously, the legal team, marketing and business and technical architects need to be involved, too.
The whole program is typically overseen by a chief sustainability officer, an ESG manager or product manager.


What is the end-to-end process behind the calculation and the preparation of product life cycle data to make it fit for scoring?

First, you need to collect data from suppliers. Then you need to verify the data with internal quality teams.

If the product is already in the GDSN network, you need to verify the correctness of data on the labels, ingredients and certification. However, if the product is new, the data collected is only verified internally.

Once the data is collected the product is mapped to an Agribalyse category available in Présentation - Eco-Score. This mapping can be complex and based on the complete property of the product. If it is a fruit or meat, end-to-end details on each associated ingredient is considered such as the cut, type, condition, color, temperature, aroma, fermentation, etc. This process can be complex, requiring the involvement of dietitians or nutritionists and AI/ML with help of natural language processing (NLP) to automate the process with proper data feeds.

Once the category is mapped by considering all production stages like agriculture, processing, packaging, transportation, distribution and consumption based on environmental impact indicators, the Life Cycle Assessment score is determined. Environmental impact indicators considered include climate change, carbon footprint, ozone depletion, ionizing radiation, land, water and energy use, air and marine pollution and freshwater pollution (particulate matter, acidification, eutrophication) and resource depletion.

Then bonus and malus points are calculated on critical environmental impacts that are not completely covered by the life cycle assessments (such as biodiversity) and the specificities of each product within the same category, the reference score is modulated with bonuses and maluses on factors such as:

  • Production method: A bonus is awarded to products that have an official sign, label or certification that guarantees environmental benefits (organic, fair trade, HVE, Label Rouge, Bleu Blanc Coeur, MSC/ASC).
  • Origin of ingredients: A bonus is awarded based on the origin of the ingredients. This bonus considers the impact on transport and the environmental policy of origin country.
  • Endangered species: A malus is attributed to products containing ingredients that significantly negatively impact biodiversity and ecosystems, such as palm oil, the production of which is responsible for massive deforestation.
  • Packaging: A malus is calculated to consider the lack of packaging circularity (the use of recycled raw materials and recyclability) and over-packaging based on ability of country of activity.

Finally, the scores are summed up to get the final Eco-Score

It is critical to note that any data correction can require resources from supplier or the quality department, calculation engines, or reviewers of product or sustainability data – thereby making it a highly time-consuming and costly process.

Obviously, that is quite a charge on retailers to assess product life cycles and get their sustainability data in order. What is your experience of the amount of manual work behind the calculation, and whether some of the process can be automated?

There is a considerable effort in collecting all data from suppliers before even the calculation can begin. In many cases, new methods of data sourcing are used due to the lack of sustainability-specific data capturing tools. This causes double effort from suppliers to enter the data multiple times in various sources.

In the case of manual data entry, there are data quality and governance checks to be done, as the sustainability data is sensitive and can impact a brand image and supplier relationships if erroneous data is released.

Then comes the calculation part, which even if automated, needs to be verified against simulated values to ensure the correctness of data and consistency with standard data sources. For example, the label/certification declaration should match the market declarations (like GDSN); any deviation can even bring legal problems.

Then any correction of data is done in consensus with the supplier, which takes more time. In many cases, this is done by emailing or over the phone communication, which can have its own carbon footprint to be analytically critical about it.

Any clarification or change in method is cumbersome as it needs to be verified by the consortium, and suppliers need to be made aware of changes. In some cases, massive data corrections are needed.

As far as automation is concerned, the Eco-Score calculation can be automated.

Also, the mapping of the Agribalyse category can be automated by use of NLP and AI but manual validation is still needed to ensure the correctness of sensitive data as it impacts the complete Eco-Score.

There can be automated integrations like the ADME data source integration to calculation engines or to the retailer’s own data pool.

The approval processes of any data alteration and notification to stakeholders can also be automated.


How much of the sustainability data is supplier information?

Supplier information is the basis of sustainability data. For example, in Eco-Score we cannot even get started mapping data to Agribalyse to get the Life Cycle Assessment score or any of the bonus-maluses without suppliers sharing their ingredients and origin data. Even label and certification data comes directly from the supplier or from supplier data inputs in a standard data pool like GS1.



Which sustainability data is particularly hard to get?

The mapping of the Agribalyse category based on which the Life Cycle Assessment is determined is the tricky one. But sometimes even simple things like ingredients can be difficult to identify. For example, on a croquette, is its potato starch or potato powder an ingredient? We need to know whether it is from the producer or the supplier.


What is the hardest part of sustainability data management from an operational viewpoint?

Data correction and approvals on changes that also needs to be promptly reported to all stakeholders.


Do you see any room for optimization that can make the product life cycle assessment more efficient and perhaps increase data quality?

Automated data management can save time and improve quality as sustainability data is of gigantic volume.

Collection, integration and management of data needs a data management platform for sustainability data. Any changes in incoming data or underlying regulations can trigger necessary approvals and notifications. Data from a single source used for internal and external communication will make it easier for organizations to meet sustainability goals and compliance requirements.


What is your most important lesson from working with sustainability data management in retail?

Sustainability data management is an integral part of a retailer’s product master data management, supplier data and related product information management and location data such as origin and activity region. This is crucial information for life cycle assessments and should not be treated or curated in silos. Properly governed, this data can enhance efficiency in business operations, like supply chain and marketing and impact organizational brand value. The problem is that sustainability data has many diverse sources, and when kept isolated, a lot of effort is needed to correct any discrepancy and avoid miscommunications. Therefore, a single source of information is, as well as a solid data governance strategy, is necessary.


What advice will you give to grocery retailers who are at the beginning of their sustainability journey?

Retailers have a cumbersome journey ahead of them, but the good news is that the industry’s sustainability initiatives are supported by political strategy, climate needs and consumer choices. Time is in favor of those who are acting now. Retailers have an opportunity to translate this effort into new business.

Retailers' unique position in the supply chain between upstream suppliers and downstream consumers is the key to a holistic circular economy opportunity. Retailers can promote sustainable consumption by offering sustainable products and information campaigns and sustainable production by enforcing responsible procurement policies of suppliers.

To be able to pull the sustainability lever with power, retailers need to onboard specialists who understand data, and they need to invest in processes and technology that can deliver correct data at the right time.

Retailers also need to focus on managing sustainability data from the source and eliminate silos, which requires clean and precise data management. As most of the sustainability information is convergent with master data, it is important to have the correct information from the beginning available to all stakeholders.

Master Data Management Blog by Stibo Systems logo

Mickaël Pluchon is Senior Pre-Sales Consultant at Stibo Systems. He has more than 15 years international experience in the IT and data management business. At Stibo Systems, he applies his knowledge to help retailers and manufacturers grow their business through enhanced data management.

Discover Blogs by Topic

  • MDM strategy
  • Data governance
  • Customer and party data
  • See more
  • Retail and distribution
  • Manufacturing
  • Data quality
  • Supplier data
  • Product data and PIM
  • AI and machine learning
  • CPG
  • Financial services
  • GDPR
  • Sustainability
  • Location data
  • PDX Syndication

The Difference Between Master Data and Metadata


Master Data Management Roles and Responsibilities


8 Best Practices for Customer Master Data Management


What Is Master Data Governance – And Why Do You Need It?


Guide: Deliver flawless rich content experiences with master data governance


Risks of Using LLMs in Your Business – What Does OWASP Have to Say?


Guide: How to comply with industry standards using master data governance


Digital Product Passports - A Data Management Challenge


Guide: Get enterprise data enrichment right with master data governance


Guide: Getting enterprise data modelling right with master data governance


Guide: Improving your data quality with master data governance


Data Governance Trends 2024


NRF 2024 Recap: In the AI era, better data can make all the difference


Building Supply Chain Resilience: Strategies & Examples


How Master Data Management Can Enhance Your ERP Solution


Shedding Light on Climate Accountability and Traceability in Retail


What is Smart Manufacturing and Why Does it Matter?


Future Proof Your Retail Business with Composable Commerce


5 Common Reasons Why Manufacturers Fail at Digital Transformation


How to Digitally Transform a Restaurant Chain


Three Benefits of Moving to Headless Commerce and the Role of a Modern PIM


12 Steps to a Successful Omnichannel and Unified Commerce


CGF Global Summit 2023: Unlock Sustainable Growth With Collaboration and Innovation


Navigating the Current Challenges of Supply Chain Management


Responsible AI relies on data governance


Product Data Management during Mergers and Acquisitions


A Complete Master Data Management Glossary


4 Ways to Reduce Ecommerce Returns


Asset Data Governance is Central for Asset Management


4 Common Master Data Management Implementation Styles


How to Leverage Internet of Things with Master Data Management


Manufacturing Trends and Insights in 2023-2025


Sustainability in Retail Needs Governed Data


What is Augmented Data Management? (ADM)


NRF 2023: Retail Turns to AI and Automation to Increase Efficiencies


What is the difference between CPG and FMCG?


5 Key Manufacturing Challenges in 2023


What is a Golden Customer Record in Master Data Management?


The Future of Master Data Management: Trends in 2023-2025


Innovation in Retail


5 CPG Industry Trends and Opportunities for 2023-2025


Life Cycle Assessment Scoring for Food Products


Retail of the Future


Omnichannel Strategies for Retail


Hyper-Personalized Customer Experiences Need Multidomain MDM


What is Omnichannel Retailing and What is the Role of Data Management?


Most Common ISO Standards in the Manufacturing Industry


How to Get Started with Master Data Management: 5 Steps to Consider


What is Supply Chain Analytics and Why It's Important


What is Data Quality and Why It's Important


A Data Monetization Strategy - Get More Value from Your Master Data


An Introductory Guide: What is Data Intelligence?


Revolutionizing Manufacturing: 5 Must-Have SaaS Systems for Success


An Introductory Guide to Supplier Compliance


What is Application Data Management and How Does It Differ From MDM?


Digital Transformation in the Manufacturing Industry


Master Data Management Framework: Get Set for Success


Discover the Value of Your Data: Master Data Management KPIs & Metrics


Supplier Self-Service: Everything You Need to Know


Omnichannel vs. Multichannel: What’s the Difference?


Digital Transformation in the CPG Industry


Create a Culture of Data Transparency - Begin with a Solid Foundation


The 5 Biggest Retail Trends for 2023-2025


What is a Location Intelligence?


Omnichannel Customer Experience: The Ultimate Guide


Location Analytics – All You Need to Know


Omnichannel Commerce: Creating a Seamless Shopping Experience


Top 4 Data Management Trends in the Insurance Industry


What is Supply Chain Visibility and Why It's Important


6 Features of an Effective Master Data Management Solution


What is Digital Asset Management?


The Ultimate Guide to Data Transparency


How Manufacturers Can Shift to Product-as-a-Service Offerings


How to Check Your Enterprise Data Foundation


An Introductory Guide to Manufacturing Compliance


Multidomain MDM vs. Multiple Domain MDM


Making Master Data Accessible: What is Data as a Service (DaaS)?


How to Build a Successful Data Governance Strategy


What is Unified Commerce? Key Advantages & Best Practices


How to Choose the Right Data Quality Tool?


What is a data domain? Meaning & examples


6 Best Practices for Data Governance


5 Advantages of a Master Data Management System


A Unified Customer View: What Is It and Why You Need It


Supply Chain Challenges in the CPG Industry


Data Migration to SAP S/4HANA ERP - The Fast and Safe Approach with MDM


The Best Data Governance Tools You Need to Know About


Top 5 Most Common Data Quality Issues


What Is Synthetic Data and Why It Needs Master Data Management


What is Cloud Master Data Management?


How to Implement Data Governance


Build vs. Buy Master Data Management Software


Why is Data Governance Important?


Five Reasons Your Data Governance Initiative Could Fail


How to Turn Your Data Silos Into Zones of Insight


How to Improve Supplier Experience Management


​​How to Improve Supplier Onboarding


How to Enable a Single Source of Truth with Master Data Management


What is a Data Quality Framework?


How to Measure the ROI of Master Data Management


What is Manufacturing-as-a-Service (MaaS)?


The Ultimate Guide to Building a Data Governance Framework


Introducing the Master Data Management Maturity Model


Master Data Management Tools - and Why You Need Them


The Dynamic Duo of Data Security and Data Governance


How to Choose the Right Supplier Management Solution


How Data Transparency Enables Sustainable Retailing


What is Supplier Performance Management?


What is Party Data? All You Need to Know About Party Data Management


What is Data Compliance? An Introductory Guide


How to Create a Marketing Center of Excellence


The Complete Guide: How to Get a 360° Customer View


How Location Data Adds Value to Master Data Projects


How Marketers Should Prepare for the 2023 Holiday Shopping Season


What is Supplier Lifecycle Management?


What is a Data Mesh? A Simple Introduction


How to Build a Master Data Management Strategy


10 Signs You Need a Master Data Management Platform


What Vendor Data Is and Why It Matters to Manufacturers


3 Reasons High-Quality Supplier Data Can Benefit Any Organization


4 Trends in the Automotive Industry


What is Reference Data and Reference Data Management?


What Obstacles Are Impacting the Global Retail Recovery?


GDPR as a Catalyst for Effective Data Governance


All You Need to Know About Supplier Information Management


5 Tips for Driving a Centralized Data Management Strategy


Data Governance and Data Protection: A Match Made in Heaven?


Welcome to the Decade of Transparency


How to Become a Customer-Obsessed Brand


How to Create a Master Data Management Roadmap in Five Steps


What is a Data Catalog? Definition and Benefits


How to Improve the Retail Customer Experience with Data Management


How to Improve Your Data Management


How to Choose the Right Master Data Management Solution


Business Intelligence and Analytics: What's the Difference?


Spending too much on Big Data? Try Small Data and MDM


What is a Data Lake? Everything You Need to Know


How to Extract More Value from Your Data


Are you making decisions based on bad HCO/HCP information?


Why Master Data Cleansing is Important to CPG Brands


CRM 2.0 – It All Starts With Master Data Management


5 Trends in Telecom that Rely on Transparency of Master Data


10 Data Management Trends in Financial Services


Seasonal Marketing Campaigns: What Is It and Why Is It Important?


What Is a Data Fabric and Why Do You Need It?


Transparent Product Information in Pharmaceutical Manufacturing


How to Improve Back-End Systems Using Master Data Management


8 Benefits of Transparent Product Information for Medical Devices


How Retailers Can Increase Online Sales in 2023


Master Data Management (MDM) & Big Data


Key Benefits of Knowing Your Customers


Women in Master Data: Kelly Amavisca, Ferguson


Customer Data in Corporate Banking Reveal New Opportunities


How to Analyze Customer Data With Customer Master Data Management


How to Improve Your 2023 Black Friday Sales in 5 Steps


4 Ways Product Information Management (PIM) Improves the Customer Experience


How to Estimate the ROI of Your Customer Data


Women in Master Data: Rebecca Chamberlain, M&S


How to Personalise Insurance Solutions with MDM


How to Democratize Your Data


How to Get Buy-In for a Master Data Management Solution


How CPG Brands Manage the Impact of Covid-19 in a Post-Pandemic World


5 Steps to Improve Your Data Syndication


Marketing Data Quality: Why Is It Important and How to Get Started


Panic Buying: Navigating Long-term Implications and Uncertainty


Women in Master Data: Ditte Brix, IMPACT


Get More Value From Your CRM With Customer Master Data Management


Women in Master Data: Nagashree Devadas, Stibo Systems


How to Create Direct-to-Consumer (D2C) Success for CPG Brands


Women in Master Data: Anna Schéle, Ahlsell


Women in Master Data: Morgan Lawrence, Infoverity


Women in Master Data: Sara Friberg, Acando (Part of CGI)


Improving Product Setup Processes Enhances Superior Experiences


How to Improve Your Product's Time to Market With PDX Syndication


8 Tips For Pricing Automation In The Aftermarket


How to Drive Innovation With Master Data Management


Discover PDX Syndication to Launch New Products with Speed


How to Benefit from Product Data Management


What is a Product Backlog and How to Avoid It


How to Get Rid of Customer Duplicates


4 Types of IT Systems That Should Be Sunsetted


How to Use Customer Data Modeling


How to Reduce Time-to-Market with Master Data Management


How to Start Taking Advantage of Your Data


6 Signs You Have a Potential GDPR Problem


GDPR: The DOs and DON’Ts of Personal Data


How Master Data Management Supports Data Security


Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ) About the GDPR


Understanding the Role of a Chief Data Officer


3 Steps: How to Plan, Execute and Evaluate Any IoT Initiative


How to Benefit From Customer-Centric Data Management


3 Ways to Faster Innovation with Multidomain Master Data Management


Product Information Management Trends to Consider


4 Major GDPR Challenges and How to Solve Them


How to Prepare for GDPR in Five Steps


How Data Can Help Fight Counterfeit Pharmaceuticals


Create the Best Customer Experience with a Customer Data Platform